33:64 presents “Robert Palmer.”
I found myself in a curious situation the other day. I found myself agreeing with Andy Crapp. He said that the UK had “lost more than we’ve gained” after Brexit. This is undeniably true. But it quickly transpired that we have wildly different opinions about what exactly it is that had been lost.
Addressing the Welsh Labour conference last Saturday, he said the Tories’ exit deal was “harsher and harder” than the electorate had voted for. And the fault was all theirs. They were to blame. Because they “burned all of our bridges” with EU leaders.
Clearly then, he knew his audience. The way that he constantly belted out the old crowd pleasers because he knew that’s what they want to hear. Blame everything on Brexit. Blame the Tories for Brexit. Blame them for the deal. Blame the deal for the state of ‘now’. But ‘now’ can be ‘reset’ This reduces Brexit to nothing more than putting the clocks back or turning a computer on and off again. It also lets the EU off the hook.
Because the EU had a vested interest in making the Brexit deal as unfavourable to Britain as it possibly could. They were focused on sending a clear message to the other European countries who were keenly observing Britains fate. Because in 2016, more than half of all EU member states had either prominent populist or hard Eurosceptic parties, who were calling for EU membership referendums or withdrawal from the EU altogether. Three of whom – France, The Netherlands and Italy – were facing especially strong domestic political pressure for their own referendum on membership. So the EU’s negotiating position was basically, “You want to leave? Fine. But it’ll be on our terms, terms that’ll be so punitive, that no-one else will want to follow suit.”
And fair play to them, it worked. Because immediately following the Brexit vote, several political parties across the continent pushed for similar exit votes in their own countries. However, when the economic and political complexities of Brexit became apparent and the harsh realities of emulating it became abundantly clear, such calls quickly returned to the fringes.
Therefore blaming the Tories alone for a Brexit deal that did the UK no favours is deluded nonsense. It may well be a nonsense that plays well to to those for whom the EU is a paragon of political purity and therefore can do no wrong. But as the saying has it, “It takes two to tango.” And if one of those two is constantly changing the music, before stopping dancing altogether, blindfolding the other and switching to boules, krachtbal or fingerhakeln instead, then can one in all conscience blame the other party?
The biggest loss though, is the loss of trust in politics. A trust that is all too evident in appalling low voter turnouts at elections since Brexit. But moreover, one that the Labour Party in particular, is quite happy to perpetuate. Just months ago the electorate – well the part of them that voted for Brexit anyway – were reminded of just how keen the new PM is to regain their trust.
When he needed the voters in Makefield to elect him as their MP and send him to Downing Street, he was all kinds of warm words about respecting the Brexit vote. But as soon as they had, it was back to business as usual. His primary business being looking after his own business. He knows full well Labour, well the MP’s who coronated him PM, want back into Europe. So he’s doing his best to make their nightmare a reality for the rest of us.
But almost as soon as the result of Brexit vote was called back in 2016, trust started to ebb away. No better example of this was provided by Shed. He’d decided to hold the referendum in the first place and because the answer wasn’t the one he was expecting, he flounced off. A true statesman. He left the country in a right state. Precisely when time was of the essence, when preparations for negotiations needed to be formulated, Britain was instead plunged into a leadership contest.
It didn’t really matter though, I mean it didn’t exactly help but really, what could help Brexit to be the success the people who made it happen wanted? They were vilified by the media, their motives questioned and suggestions of manipulation abounded. The BBC was the worst. Rather than remain impartial and just report the news as simple facts, its reporters were allowed to commentate on – and give their own opinions about – the turmoil that they themselves were helping to ferment. If any airtime was given to those who argued that losers consent was vital if a democracy was to sustain itself, it wasn’t on Radio 4. I’d’ve known. I was living in a house with Remoaners back in 2016. It was all they listened to.
Demands for a second referendum were given credence, amplfied by people who believed in democracy alright. Just as long as it was the kind of democracy that suited them. Remember Windy Miller? She won a Supreme Court case against the government regarding its authority to trigger Brexit without Parliamentary approval. That was a good look. A wealthy individual brings a case to the Supreme Court – made up of equally unelected people – to prevent the democratically expressed will of the people being carried out.
But why, one has to ask, is the Labour party still so enamoured with the EU in 2026? What is the attraction? Why do they imagine that rejoining the EU is is a vote winner and why has it become an almost totemic belief among their MP’s? Free movement of EU citizens, which is a non-negotiable pre-condition of membership, actively works against the interests of Britons. Not British architects, industrial designers or others with a skill that might land them a job in Antwerp or Milan. But the sort of British people who founded the Labour Party in the first place, members of the trade unions who wanted a parliamentary voice.
They’d see it as a betrayal. And they’d be right to. Free movement of people is a capitalist’s wet dream. Dress it up however you want but in a nutshell it allows EU nationals to come here and work for less than than British person would. This also adds to a welfare bill that’s already out of control. Tax credits and housing benefit for those in work. Getting signed off sick for those who’ve decided the allure of daytime TV is simply irresistible.
Another thing we’ve lost is a civil society. One that accepts a multiplicity of views as necessary precursor to achieve consensus. A tolerance of views different to others but which must be aired, if they are to be challenged and possibly defeated. That no longer exists, thats gone and it doesn’t look like its ever coming back. And Brexit is partly to blame for that. The rigid absolutism of the Remoaners is all too visible in a Green Party which is defiantly pro-genocide and blatantly anti-women.
So yes, I agree with Andy Crapp we’ve lost. But we don’t agree on what it is we’ve lost.
Oh, I should point out, that I voted to Remain. Not that it should make a blind bit of difference.